This year, ICE (United States Immigration and Customs Enforcement) has earned a spot on the “Turkeys of the Year” list—not because enforcing laws is automatically wrong, but because the way enforcement happens matters. When federal agents’ actions leave people hurt, frightened, or unsure whether the rules are being followed, the whole country has a reason to ask whether the system is working. A badge should come with a responsibility, not a free pass.
Two fatal shootings in Minneapolis have raised serious questions about ICE and other federal agents’ use of force. Renee Good was killed on January 7, and Alex Pretti was killed on January 24. Those are not just names in a headline; they were people whose deaths left families grieving and communities demanding answers. When video and official statements appear to tell different stories, public trust takes another hit.
The criticism is not only about individual encounters. An immigration-law analysis says the administration expanded the use of arrests during enforcement operations, including cases where warrants were prepared in the field or after someone had already been stopped. That raises a basic fairness question: should the paperwork come first, or should people be arrested first and the paperwork catch up later? This is the kind of process that makes “trust us” a pretty weak explanation.
There are also concerns about preparation and accountability. A Brookings article reports that ICE training was shortened and some language training was removed, while the agency rapidly expanded hiring. That is a worrying combination for work that involves people’s safety, legal rights, and families. Clear training and strong oversight are important for protecting the public and maintaining trust.
ICE agents are not all the same, and enforcing immigration laws is a real government responsibility. But a government agency should protect public safety while respecting people’s rights and explain its actions openly when serious harm occurs. When enforcement creates fear, deaths, and doubts about basic fairness, it can weaken trust in the whole country. For those reasons, ICE’s actions and the policies behind them belong on this year’s turkey list—not as a joke about people’s suffering, but as a serious warning that public power needs stronger rules and accountability.
